Old Colony Homes For Sale
What this community is known for:Old Colony is a traditional Old Lyme shoreline neighborhood known for its private beach access, strong seasonal ownership, and mix of classic cottages and updated coastal homes.
Located along the Long Island Sound in Old Lyme, Old Colony offers a relaxed coastal lifestyle with a strong sense of community. Many properties are used as second homes, giving the neighborhood a seasonal rhythm that defines its character.
Shoreline Lifestyle
Life in Old Colony revolves around the beach and the outdoors. Residents enjoy swimming, kayaking, paddleboarding, fishing, and long walks along the shoreline. During the summer months, the community becomes more active as seasonal residents return.
In the off-season, Old Colony offers a quieter and more peaceful coastal environment, making it appealing to both full-time residents and second-home owners.
Housing & Community Character
Homes in Old Colony range from smaller original beach cottages to expanded or fully rebuilt coastal residences. Many properties retain traditional New England shoreline architecture, while others have been modernized to meet current expectations.
Because properties vary in condition, elevation, and proximity to the water, pricing can differ significantly even within the same neighborhood.
Typical Property Profile
- Lot size: approximately 0.10 acres
- Year built: around 1940
- Living area: approximately 1,040 square feet
- Bedrooms: typically 3 bedrooms
There are currently 179 homesin Old Colony that are utilized as second homes rather than year-round residences. This represents approximately 75% of the neighborhood, giving the area a strong seasonal ownership profile.
What Buyers Should Know
- Old Colony has a strong seasonal and second-home ownership base.
- Flood zones, elevation, and insurance requirements can vary by property.
- Some homes remain original cottages, while others have been rebuilt or expanded.
- Pricing is influenced by proximity to the water, condition, and modernization.
Understanding how a specific property compares to others in the same community—and how Old Colony fits within the broader Old Lyme shoreline—can have a major impact on long-term value.
Advisory-First Approach
At Seaport Real Estate Services, our approach is advisory-first. We help clients understand pricing, condition, flood considerations, seasonal ownership patterns, and long-term market behavior before making decisions.
In shoreline communities like Old Colony, the right decision often comes down to the tradeoffs between location, elevation, condition, and future costs. Our role is to help you evaluate those factors clearly.
← See how this fits into Our Process
Thinking About Old Colony?
If you’re considering Old Colony, we can help you compare it to other Old Lyme shoreline neighborhoods and determine which location best fits your goals, budget, and long-term plans.
Schedule an Advisory Conversation
- All Listings
- $500,000 - $600,000
- $600,000 - $700,000
Nearby Old Lyme Shoreline Communities
Each Old Lyme shoreline neighborhood has its own personality, seasonal rhythm, and pricing dynamics. Buyers often compare several communities before deciding where they feel most at home.
- Hawks Nest – A classic seasonal beach community near the Lieutenant River.
- Point O’Woods – Private beach living with a strong seasonal rhythm.
- Old Lyme Shores – A traditional private beach neighborhood with a loyal seasonal base.
- Sound View – A well-known shoreline area with its own distinct market.
- Miami Beach – A seasonal shoreline neighborhood with a relaxed coastal feel.
- White Sands – A quieter shoreline pocket often compared by beach buyers.
If you’re exploring the Old Lyme shoreline, we can help you compare these communities side by side to determine which one best fits your goals.
Searching for a property in a waterfront community and not finding exactly what you are looking for? Contact a member of Seaport Real Estate Services to explore off-market opportunities along the Connecticut and Rhode Island coastline. We are here to help you find the right property that may not otherwise be visible to the marketplace.